Maintenance and sustainability across the life cycle of assets
Caring for things means preserving their value and making informed decisions about when to repair, improve or replace them.
In this editorial
- Every component has its own service life
- Care also reduces waste during use
- Repairing or replacing requires a fair comparison
- An example shows why the answer can change
- The ability to repair is also decided at purchase
- Measure the service obtained and the resources used
- Care requires skills and responsibility
- European policies recognise the value of durability
- Make value last
A leaking seal, a noisy bearing, a worn-out battery. The fate of a complex item often depends on a small part. If the defect is identified and addressed in time, the rest can continue to do its job. If it is neglected, or the component is inaccessible or unavailable, an assembly that is still largely usable may need to be replaced.
This is where maintenance meets sustainability: in our ability to obtain useful service from the assets we own while using the necessary resources wisely. The aim is a useful, safe and efficient service life. Repair may be the best choice; in other cases, an upgrade or a justified replacement will be preferable. The decisive question concerns the service we still need and the impacts of the available alternatives.
Every component has its own service life
A plant, a bicycle or a piece of gym equipment brings together parts with different lifespans. Structures, cables, seals, electronics and surfaces subject to wear do not age together. Assets of the same chronological age can have different remaining useful lives. [12] The life of the weakest component should not automatically determine the life of the entire system.
Retaining a sound structure and replacing a worn part can preserve the manufacturing work, materials and expertise already embodied in an asset. Recycling recovers materials; repair can also preserve the function of the item. Reuse, refurbishment and remanufacturing offer further options, to be chosen according to condition and required performance. [1]
This reasoning must, however, start with future consequences. The impacts of past production have already occurred: they do not become a credit to subtract every time we repair something. Any potential benefit lies in the new production activities and consumption that the decision actually avoids, compared with a credible alternative. Reuse must likewise be assessed against the purchases it genuinely replaces. [13]
Care also reduces waste during use
Service life is only part of the outcome. Water or compressed-air leaks, deteriorated insulation and incorrect settings can consume resources without increasing the service delivered. Well-directed maintenance also addresses these inefficiencies. [2]
For example, repairing a water leak may also reduce pumping, treatment and, if the water is hot, the heat required. A malfunctioning component can also generate rejects or damage other parts. The cost of the defect can therefore extend well beyond the price of a spare part.
Maintenance work also consumes resources: spare parts, lubricants, cleaning products, travel and materials requiring disposal. Routinely replacing parts that remain fit for purpose can introduce waste and new assembly errors. Frequencies and methods should be chosen with regard to criticality, applicable instructions, observed condition and the consequences of failure. Where a defect can put people or the environment at risk, immediate savings do not justify delay.
Repairing or replacing requires a fair comparison
The repair quotation is important information, but it is not enough. The decision needs to address some practical questions.
- Can the restored asset deliver the required service safely and in compliance with applicable requirements?
- What caused the defect, and how likely is it to recur?
- How much useful life can reasonably be expected after the work, with what consumption and maintenance needs?
- Does the new, refurbished or upgraded alternative offer a measurable improvement under actual operating conditions?
- What resources do production, transport, installation and end-of-life treatment require for the different alternatives?
The comparison must cover the same function, the same level of service and the same period. Spare-part availability, downtime, skills and the user's overall cost also matter. A fixed threshold based on the ratio of repair cost to the price of a new item cannot answer all these questions on its own.
For assets that consume energy, durability and efficiency must be considered together: this is the methodological issue also addressed by the Joint Research Centre. [3] If the alternatives have different lifespans, any subsequent replacements must be included, and remaining useful life at the end of the comparison period must be treated consistently.
An example shows why the answer can change
Consider three alternatives that provide the same service for five years. All the numbers are invented for illustration. Consumption and the electricity emissions factor are assumed to remain constant, the residual condition at the end is identical, and all other impact contributions are equal and therefore cancel out. The hypothetical factor is 0.25 kg CO₂e per kWh.
| Item | Repair | New A | New B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Impact of the initial intervention | 20 kg CO₂e | 220 kg CO₂e | 220 kg CO₂e |
| Annual electricity consumption | 2,000 kWh | 1,900 kWh | 1,600 kWh |
| Initial impact plus five years of use | 2,520 kg CO₂e | 2,595 kg CO₂e | 2,220 kg CO₂e |
The total is calculated by adding the initial impact to annual consumption multiplied by five years and by the electricity emissions factor. New A saves little energy: over the five years considered, repair has a lower climate impact. New B reduces consumption more substantially and offsets its greater initial impact within the period.
Under these assumptions, the climate break-even time is eight years for A and two for B: the initial difference of 200 kg CO₂e is divided by the annual savings, respectively 25 and 100 kg CO₂e. The eight-year figure is a mathematical extension of the assumptions, not a prediction of the assets' service life.
This exercise considers only one indicator. A real case requires data on reliability, subsequent maintenance, transport, end of life and changes in the electricity system, as well as materials, water and other impacts. It is neither a full LCA nor an assessment of conformity with ISO 14040 and ISO 14044, which provide methodological references for life cycle assessment. [4], [5]
The ability to repair is also decided at purchase
Repairability deserves an assessment of its own. [6] Before purchasing, it is worth asking how wear parts can be accessed, how long spare parts will remain available, which tools are needed and who can carry out the work. Documentation, compatibility and continued software support also matter where required.
A low purchase price may come with a sealed component, a disproportionately expensive spare part or a dependency that is difficult to manage. Conversely, a modular design is not automatically better in every application: accessibility, robustness and performance must still be suitable.
Purchasing teams can make these criteria explicit in specifications and comparisons of offers. A refurbished component can also be considered, provided its condition, traceability, relevant tests and warranties are clear. Maintenance should be able to contribute to the selection before the asset arrives, while many options are still open.
Measure the service obtained and the resources used
Counting completed maintenance jobs does not, by itself, demonstrate improvement. A hundred repairs may indicate care, or a recurring problem that has never been resolved. An understandable asset history is needed: defects, causes, replaced parts, measurements before and after, downtime and the reasons behind decisions.
An initial set of indicators can track energy or water per unit of service, time between comparable interventions, recurring failures, quantities of materials replaced and the total cost of service. The measure must suit the application: for example, kWh per cubic metre pumped under comparable conditions, rather than annual consumption alone. Activity, loads and external conditions can change and must be taken into account.
A CMMS can organise this evidence; data quality and the basis of comparison remain decisive. Emissions hypothetically avoided compared with replacement should be presented as scenario estimates, with explicit assumptions, without automatically treating them as reductions in the organisation's emissions inventory. [14] No universal percentage describes the environmental benefit of every maintenance activity.
For M@Post, maintenance management contributes to sustainability through this discipline: connecting a reported issue to a decision, the intervention to an observable result, and that result to a better choice next time. Asset management requires performance, risk and expenditure to be considered together. [7]
Care requires skills and responsibility
An asset's sustainability also depends on the people who use and maintain it. Clear instructions, timely reporting and enough time to work properly make everyday care practicable. Planning maintenance also helps organise work safely. [8]
In a small business, a hotel, a gym or a local authority, the question is often very practical: who recognises the anomaly, who decides and who checks that proper operation has been restored? Clear responsibility can prevent a minor defect from remaining unanswered until failure occurs. Specialist work, electrical work and tasks involving other sources of danger require suitable skills and working conditions.
European policies recognise the value of durability
The European waste hierarchy gives priority to prevention. [9] The right to repair covers specific categories of consumer goods, rather than all industrial machinery indiscriminately. [10] The ESPR establishes a framework for product sustainability requirements, to be specified through the applicable provisions. [11]
This European reference must be kept distinct from the rules applicable in other countries. For asset managers, the practical direction is nevertheless clear: ask about durability, repairability and the information needed to make decisions. Specific obligations must be checked for the product and jurisdiction concerned.
Make value last
Caring well for things makes sustainability an everyday choice. It begins with purchasing an asset that can be maintained, continues with recognising deterioration and measuring the outcome of an intervention, and extends to the decision to reuse, upgrade or retire it.
A successful repair restores service. A well-justified replacement can reduce consumption or risk. In both cases, the best outcome comes from a documented decision based on the asset's actual condition and the work it still needs to do. This is how maintenance can help use resources more wisely and preserve value over time.
Sources and further reading
- UNEP International Resource Panel (2018). Re-defining Value: The Manufacturing Revolution.
- US Department of Energy Federal Energy Management Program (2026). Operations and Maintenance in Federal Facilities.
- Fulvio Ardente and Fabrice Mathieux (2014). Environmental assessment of the durability of energy-using products: method and application. DOI 10.1016/j.jclepro.2014.03.049.
- ISO (2006). ISO 14040:2006 — Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — Principles and framework.
- ISO (2006). ISO 14044:2006 — Environmental management — Life cycle assessment — Requirements and guidelines.
- Ellen Bracquené et al. (2021). Analysis of evaluation systems for product repairability: a case study for washing machines. DOI 10.1016/j.jclepro.2020.125122.
- ISO (2024). ISO 55001:2024 — Asset management — Asset management system — Requirements.
- Suva (2022). Pianificare e controllare la manutenzione — La premessa per lavorare con efficienza e in piena sicurezza — 66121.I.
- European Commission (consulted 2026). Waste Framework Directive.
- European Commission (consulted 2026). Directive on repair of goods — Directive (EU) 2024/1799.
- European Commission (consulted 2026). Ecodesign for Sustainable Products Regulation — Regulation (EU) 2024/1781.
- Tom Obdam Henk Braam René van de Pieterman and Luc Rademakers (2011). O&M Cost Estimation & Feedback of Operational Data. DOI 10.5772/17011.
- European Environment Agency (2024 updated 2025). Product lifespans — monitoring trends in Europe. DOI 10.2800/3674834.
- GHG Protocol (2025). What about accounting for reductions outside of scope 3?.